The Deepest Well | Katie Rice ‘27

“But when they sat beside me, their hands in my hands, my own suffering began to feel like it had revealed to me the suffering of others. I was entering a world of people just like me, people stumbling around in the debris of dreams they thought they were entitled to and plans they didn’t realize they had made. It was a feeling of being more connected, somehow, with other people, experiencing the same situation.” – Kate Bowler, Everything Happens for a Reason: And Other Lies I’ve Loved


Huddled around the dinner table with the other Horizons Fellows, I put a star next to the lines above in my notebook. Kate Bowler, a Canadian author and professor, grapples with her human need for control as she battles Stage IV colon cancer in her bestselling book Everything Happens for a Reason.

Our Fellows gathering isn’t the first time I’ve reckoned with Bowler’s tough questions. I first read her memoir while studying abroad last year and found it disquieting. Bowler challenges our closely held ideas about getting what we deserve, and while I was trekking through my third year, that proposition was not what I wanted to hear. This year, after experiencing disappointment like never before, I found myself leaning into Bowler’s assertions. Sometimes hard things simply happen, without any reason we can find, and the path ahead becomes unclear.

That uncertainty has changed how I see growing up. As a fourth-year, I am finally able to understand that every “real adult” I know is also doing life for the first time. The adversity I have stared down this year has, paradoxically, made me less self-centered. It has also left me with a deeper feeling of connection to the world and to the similarities we all share, or as my dad puts it, “the deep well of sorrow all humans draw from.” 

I heard a similar sentiment from my mentor. At our first meeting, over steaming cups of tea, she said to me: “I just want you to know I don’t have it all together. I’m still figuring out my life, too.” While this isn’t exactly what I wanted to hear (life isn’t linear, bad things happen, and we don’t know why), her vulnerability has given me space to connect with her authentically.

Hard things breed humility, which leads to compassion and strengthens relationships. Eventually, as Bowler illustrates, we see ourselves and the world around us clearly for the first time: I will suffer. You will suffer. It is within this deep well that we most fully connect to each other, and in my experience, to the God who is waiting for us.

In my Bible class, we just finished Ecclesiastes, in which the narrator, Kohelet, teaches that everything is “hevel,” or breath. Nothing is permanent, and we cannot fully understand why our lives unfold the way they do. In chapter 4, verses 9–10, he observes that “Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other; but woe to one who is alone and falls and does not have another to help.”

When we embrace the vulnerability our suffering creates in us, and draw from our deepest well, we are able to know and be fully known by others. We are no longer alone. As Kohelet says, if we fall, someone is there to lift us up. 

Previous
Previous

On Calling and Constraint | Helen Yingling ’27

Next
Next

We Need Each Other | Elika Tofigh ‘28